“I’m very sorry,” I said,“but I wish you had told me all about it. Won’t you now?Just the bare, matter-of-fact truth. I hate sentiment, and so do you.”
“I find it very difficult to tell people things,” said Davies, “things like this.” I waited.“I did like her—very much.” Our eyes met for a second,in which all was said that need be said,as between two of our phlegmatic race.“And she’s—separate from him.That was the reason of all my indecisions.” he hurried on. “I only told you half at Schlei.I know I ought to have been open,and asked your advice. But I let it slide.I’ve been hoping all along that we might find what we want and win the game without coming to close quarters again.”
I no longer wondered at his devotion to the channel theory,since, built on conviction,it was thus doubly fortified.
“Yet you always knew what might happen,” I said.“At Schlei you spoke of ‘settling with’ Dollmann.”
“I know. When I thought of him I was mad.I made myself forget the other part.”
“Which recurred at Brunsbüttel?” I thought of the news we had there.
“Yes.”
“Davies, we must have no more secrets.I’m going to speak out.Are you sure you’ve not misunderstood her?You say—and I’m willing to assume it—that Dollmann’s a traitor and a murderer. ”
“Oh, hang the murder part!” said Davies, impatiently. “What does _that_ matter?”
“Well, traitor. Very good;but in that case I suspect his daughter. No!let me go on. She was useful, to say the least.She encouraged you—you’ve told me that—to make that passage with them. ”
“Stop, Carruthers,” said Davies, firmly.“I know you mean kindly; but it’s no use. I believe in her.”
I thought for a moment.
“In that case,” I said, “I’ve something to propose.When we get out of this place let’s sail straight away to England.” “(There, Commander von Brüning,” I thought,“you never can say I neglected your advice.”)
“No!” exclaimed Davies, starting up and facing me.“I’m hanged if we will. Think what’s at stake.Think of that traitor—plotting with Germans. My God!”
“Very good,” I said. “I’m with you for going on.But let’s face facts. We _must_ scotch Dollmann.We can’t do so without hurting _her_.”
“Can’t we _possibly_?”
“Of course not; be sensible, man. Face that. Next point;it’s absurd to hope that we need not revisit them—it’s ten to one that we must,if we’re to succeed.His attempt on you is the whole foundation of our suspicions.And we don’t even know for certain who he _is_ yet.We’re committed, I know,to going straight to Norderney now;but even if we weren’t,should we do any good by exploring and prying?It’s very doubtful. We know we’re watched,if not suspected, and that disposes of nine-tenths of our power. The channels?Yes, but is it likely they’ll let us learn them by heart,if they’re of such vital importance,even if we are thought to be _bona fide_ yachtsmen?And, seriously, apart from their value in war,which I don’t deny,are they at the root of this business?But we’ll talk about that in a moment. The point now is,what shall we do if we meet the Dollmanns?”
Beads of sweat stood on Davies’s brow.I felt like a torturer, but it could not be helped.“Tax him with having wrecked you?Our quest would be at an end!We must be friendly.You must tell the story you told to-day,and chance his believing it. If he does,so much the better; if he doesn’t,he won’t dare say so, and we still have chances.We gain time, and have a tremendous hold on him—_if_ we’re friendly.” Davies winced. I gave another turn to the screw.“Friendly with them _both,_ of course. You were before,you know; you liked her very much—you must seem to still. ”
“Oh, stop your infernal logic.”
“Shall we chuck it and go to England?” I asked again, as an inquisitor might say,“Have you had enough?” No answer. I went on: “To make it easier,you _do_ like her still.” I had roused my victim at last.
“What the devil do you mean, Carruthers?That I’m to trade on my liking for her—on her innocence, to—good God!what _do_ you mean?”
“No, no, not that. I’m not such a cad, or such a fool,or so ignorant of you.If she knows nothing of her father’s character and likes you—and you like her—and you are what you are—oh Heavens!man, face it, realise it!But what I mean is this: is she, _can_ she be, what you think?Imagine his position if we’re right about him;the vilest creature on God’s earth—a disgraceful past to have been driven to this—in the pay of Germany. I want to spare you misery.” I was going to add: “And if you’re on your guard, to increase our chances.” But the utter futility of such suggestions silenced me. What a plan I had foreshadowed!An enticing plan and a fair one, too,as against such adversaries;turning this baffling cross-current to advantage as many a time we had worked eddies of an adverse tide in these difficult seas. But Davies was Davies, and there was an end of it; his faith and simplicity shamed me. And the pity of it, the cruelty of it, was that his very qualities were his last torture, raising to the acutest pitch the conflict between love and patriotism. Remember that the latter was his dominant life-motive, and that here and now was his chance—if you would gauge the bitterness of that conflict.
It was in its last throes now.His elbows were on the table,and his twitching hands pressed on his forehead. He took them away.
“Of course we must go on. It can’t be helped, that’s all.”
“And you believe in her?”
“I’ll remember what you’ve said.There may be some way out.And—I’d rather not talk about that any more.What about the wreck?”
Further argument was futile.Davies by an effort seemed to sweep the subject from his thoughts,and I did my best to do the same.At any rate the air was cleared—we were friends;and it only remained to grapple with the main problem in the light of the morning’s interview.
Every word that I could recollect of that critical conversation I reviewed with Davies, who had imperfectly understood what he had not been directly concerned in; and, as I did so, I began to see with what cleverness each succeeding sentence of von Brüning’s was designed to suit both of two contingencies. If we were innocent travellers, he was the genial host, communicative and helpful. If we were spies, his tactics had been equally applicable. He had outdone us in apparent candour, hiding nothing which he knew we would discover for ourselves, and contriving at the same time both to gain knowledge and control of our movements, and to convey us warnings, which would only be understood if we were guilty, that we were playing an idle and perilous game, and had better desist. But in one respect we had had the advantage, and that was in the version Davies had given of his stranding on the Hohenhörn. Inscrutable as our questioner was, he let it appear not only that the incident was new to him, but that he conjectured at its sinister significance. A little cross-examination on detail would have been fatal to Davies’s version; but that was where our strength lay; he dared not cross-examine for fear of suggesting to Davies suspicions which he might never have felt. Indeed, I thought I detected that fear underlying his whole attitude towards us, and it strengthened a conviction which had been growing in me since Grimm’s furtive midnight visit, that the secret of this coast was of so important and delicate a nature that rather than attract attention to it at all, overt action against intruders would be taken only in the last resort, and on irrefragable proofs of guilty intention.

