“He purposely put me ashore.I don’t think I’m suspicious by nature,but I know something about boats and the sea.I know he could have kept close to me if he had chosen,and I saw the whole place at low water when we left those sands on the second day. Look at the chart again. Here’s the Hohenhörn bank that I showed you as blocking the road. _[See Chart A]_ It’s in two pieces—first the west and then the east. You see the Telte channel dividing into two branches and curving round it. Both branches are broad and deep, as channels go in those waters. Now, in sailing in I was nowhere near either of them. When I last saw Dollmann he must have been steering straight for the bank itself, at a point somewhere _here_, quite a mile from the northern arm of the channel, and two from the southern. I followed by compass, as you know, and found nothing but breakers ahead. How did I get through?That’s where the luck came in.I spoke of only two channels, that is,_round_ the bank—one to the north,the other to the south.But look closely and you’ll see that right through the centre of the West Hohenhörn runs another, a very narrow and winding one, so small that I hadn’t even noticed it the night before, when I was going over the chart. That was the one I stumbled into in that tailor’s fashion, as I was groping along the edge of the surf in a desperate effort to gain time. I bolted down it blindly, came out into this strip of open water, crossed that aimlessly, and brought up on the edge of the _East_ Hohenhörn, _here_. It was more than I deserved. I can see now that it was a hundred to one in favour of my striking on a bad place outside, where I should have gone to pieces in three minutes.”
“And how did Dollmann go?” I asked.
“It’s as clear as possible,” Davies answered.“He doubled back into the northern channel when he had misled me enough.Do you remember my saying that when I last saw him I _thought_ he had luffed and showed his broadside?I had another bit of luck in that.He was luffing towards the north—so it struck me through the blur—and when I in my turn came up to the bank, and had to turn one way or the other to avoid it, I think I should naturally have turned north too, as he had done. In that case I should have been done for, for I should have had a mile of the bank to skirt before reaching the north channel, and should have driven ashore long before I got there. But as a matter of fact I turned south.”
“Why?”
“Couldn’t help it. I was running on the starboard tack—boom over to port;to turn north would have meant a jibe,and as things were I couldn’t risk one.It was blowing like fits;if anything had carried away I should have been on shore in a jiffy.I scarcely thought about it at all,but put the helm down and turned her south.Though I knew nothing about it,that little central channel was now on my port hand,distant about two cables.The whole thing was luck from beginning to end.”
Helped by pluck, I thought to myself,as I tried with my landsman’s fancy to conjure up that perilous scene.As to the truth of the affair,the chart and Davies’s version were easy enough to follow,but I felt only half convinced. The “spy”,as Davies strangely called his pilot,might have honestly mistaken the course himself,outstripped his convoy inadvertently,and escaped disaster as narrowly as she did.I suggested this on the spur of the moment,but Davies was impatient.
“Wait till you hear the whole thing,” he said.“I must go back to when I first met him.I told you that on that first evening he began by being as rude as a bear and as cold as stone, and then became suddenly friendly. I can see now that in the talk that followed he was pumping me hard. It was an easy game to play, for I hadn’t seen a gentleman since Morrison left me, I was tremendously keen about my voyage, and I thought the chap was a good sportsman, even if he was a bit dark about the ducks. I talked quite freely—at least, as freely as I could with my bad German—about my last fortnight’s sailing; how I had been smelling out all the channels in and out of the islands, how interested I had been in the whole business, puzzling out the effect of the winds on the tides, the set of the currents, and so on. I talked about my difficulties, too; the changes in the buoys, the prehistoric rottenness of the English charts. He drew me out as much as he could, and in the light of what followed I can see the point of scores of his questions.
“The next day and the next I saw a good deal of him,and the same thing went on.And then there were my plans for the future.My idea was, as I told you,to go on exploring the German coast just as I had the Dutch.His idea—Heavens, how plainly I see it now!—was to choke me off,get me to clear out altogether from that part of the coast.That was why he said there were no ducks.That was why he cracked up the Baltic as a cruising-ground and shooting-ground.And that was why he broached and stuck to that plan of sailing in company direct to the Elbe. It was to _see_ me clear.
“He improved on that.”
“Yes, but after that, it’s guess-work.I mean that I can’t tell when he first decided to go one better and drown me.He couldn’t count for certain on bad weather,though he held my nose to it when it came. But,granted that he wanted to get rid of me altogether,he got a magnificent chance on that trip to the Elbe lightship.I expect it struck him suddenly,and he acted on the impulse.Left to myself I was all right;but the short cut was a grand idea of his.Everything was in its favour—wind, sea, sand, tide.He thinks I’m dead.”
“But the crew?” I said; “what about the crew?”
“That’s another thing. When he first hove to,waiting for me, of course they were on deck (two of them,I think) hauling at sheets.But by the time I had drawn up level the _Medusa_ had worn round again on her course, and no one was on deck but Dollmann at the wheel. No one overheard what he said.”
“Wouldn’t they have _seen_ you again?”
“Very likely not; the weather was very thick,and the _Dulce_ is very small.”
The incongruity of the whole business was striking me.Why should anyone want to kill Davies,and why should Davies,the soul of modesty and simplicity,imagine that anyone wanted to kill him?He must have cogent reasons,for he was the last man to give way to a morbid fancy.
“Go on,” I said. “What was his motive?A German finds an Englishman exploring a bit of German coast,determines to stop him, and even to get rid of him.It looks so far as if you were thought to be the spy."
Davies winced. “_But he’s not a German_,” he said,hotly. “He’s an Englishman.”
“An Englishman?”
“Yes, I’m sure of it. Not that I’ve much to go on.He professed to know very little English,and never spoke it,except a word or two now and then to help me out of a sentence;and as to his German,he seemed to me to speak it like a native; but,of course, I’m no judge.” Davies sighed.“That’s where I wanted someone like you.You would have spotted him at once,if he wasn’t German.I go more by a—what do you call it?—a——”
“General impression,” I suggested.
“Yes, that’s what I mean.It was something in his looks and manner;you know how different we are from foreigners.And it wasn’t only himself,it was the way he talked—I mean about cruising and the sea,especially. It’s true he let me do most of the talking;but, all the same—how can I explain it?I felt we understood one another,in a way that two foreigners wouldn’t.
“He pretended to think me a bit crazy for coming so far in a small boat,but I could swear he knew as much about the game as I did;for lots of little questions he asked had the right ring in them.Mind you, all this is an afterthought.I should never have bothered about it—I’m not cut out for a Sherlock Holmes—if it hadn’t been for what followed.”
“It’s rather vague,” I said.“Have you no more definite reason for thinking him English?”

