Kreis began directly on Martin,but step by step Norton interfered,until he and Kreis were off and away in a personal battle.Martin listened and fain would have rubbed his eyes.It was impossible that this should be,much less in the labor ghetto south of Market.The books were alive in these men.They talked with fire and enthusiasm,the intellectual stimulant stirring them as he had seen drink and anger stir other men. What he heard was no longer the philosophy of the dry, printed word, written by half-mythical demigods like Kant and Spencer. It was living philosophy, with warm, red blood, incarnated in these two men till its very features worked with excitement. Now and again other men joined in, and all followed the discussion with cigarettes going out in their hands and with alert, intent faces.
Idealism had never attracted Martin,but the exposition it now received at the hands of Norton was a revelation.The logical plausibility of it,that made an appeal to his intellect,seemed missed by Kreis and Hamilton,who sneered at Norton as a metaphysician, and who,in turn, sneered back at them as metaphysicians._Phenomenon_ and _noumenon_ were bandied back and forth.They charged him with attempting to explain consciousness by itself.He charged them with word-jugglery,with reasoning from words to theory instead of from facts to theory.At this they were aghast.It was the cardinal tenet of their mode of reasoning to start with facts and to give names to the facts.
When Norton wandered into the intricacies of Kant,Kreis reminded him that all good little German philosophies when they died went to Oxford. A little later Norton reminded them of Hamilton’s Law of Parsimony, the application of which they immediately claimed for every reasoning process of theirs. And Martin hugged his knees and exulted in it all. But Norton was no Spencerian, and he, too, strove for Martin’s philosophic soul, talking as much at him as to his two opponents.
“You know Berkeley has never been answered,” he said,looking directly at Martin.“Herbert Spencer came the nearest,which was not very near.Even the stanchest of Spencer’s followers will not go farther.I was reading an essay of Saleeby’s the other day,and the best Saleeby could say was that Herbert Spencer _nearly_ succeeded in answering Berkeley.”
“You know what Hume said?” Hamilton asked. Norton nodded,but Hamilton gave it for the benefit of the rest.“He said that Berkeley’s arguments admit of no answer and produce no conviction.”
“In his, Hume’s, mind,” was the reply.“And Hume’s mind was the same as yours,with this difference:he was wise enough to admit there was no answering Berkeley. ”
Norton was sensitive and excitable,though he never lost his head,while Kreis and Hamilton were like a pair of cold-blooded savages,seeking out tender places to prod and poke.As the evening grew late, Norton,smarting under the repeated charges of being a metaphysician,clutching his chair to keep from jumping to his feet,his gray eyes snapping and his girlish face grown harsh and sure,made a grand attack upon their position.
“All right, you Haeckelites,I may reason like a medicine man, but, pray, how do you reason?You have nothing to stand on,you unscientific dogmatists with your positive science which you are always lugging about into places it has no right to be. Long before the school of materialistic monism arose, the ground was removed so that there could be no foundation. Locke was the man, John Locke. Two hundred years ago—more than that, even in his ‘Essay concerning the Human Understanding,’ he proved the non-existence of innate ideas. The best of it is that that is precisely what you claim. To-night, again and again, you have asserted the non-existence of innate ideas.
“And what does that mean?It means that you can never know ultimate reality.Your brains are empty when you are born. Appearances,or phenomena, are all the content your minds can receive from your five senses.Then noumena, which are not in your minds when you are born,have no way of getting in—”
“I deny—” Kreis started to interrupt.
“You wait till I’m done,” Norton shouted.“You can know only that much of the play and interplay of force and matter as impinges in one way or another on our senses. You see, I am willing to admit, for the sake of the argument, that matter exists; and what I am about to do is to efface you by your own argument. I can’t do it any other way, for you are both congenitally unable to understand a philosophic abstraction.
“And now, what do you know of matter,according to your own positive science?You know it only by its phenomena, its appearances.You are aware only of its changes,or of such changes in it as cause changes in your consciousness.Positive science deals only with phenomena,yet you are foolish enough to strive to be ontologists and to deal with noumena. Yet, by the very definition of positive science, science is concerned only with appearances. As somebody has said, phenomenal knowledge cannot transcend phenomena.
“You cannot answer Berkeley,even if you have annihilated Kant, and yet, perforce,you assume that Berkeley is wrong when you affirm that science proves the non-existence of God, or, as much to the point, the existence of matter.—You know I granted the reality of matter only in order to make myself intelligible to your understanding. Be positive scientists, if you please; but ontology has no place in positive science, so leave it alone. Spencer is right in his agnosticism, but if Spencer—”
But it was time to catch the last ferry-boat for Oakland,and Brissenden and Martin slipped out,leaving Norton still talking and Kreis and Hamilton waiting to pounce on him like a pair of hounds as soon as he finished.
“You have given me a glimpse of fairyland,” Martin said on the ferry-boat.“It makes life worth while to meet people like that.My mind is all worked up.I never appreciated idealism before.Yet I can’t accept it.I know that I shall always be a realist. I am so made,I guess. But I’d like to have made a reply to Kreis and Hamilton,and I think I’d have had a word or two for Norton.I didn’t see that Spencer was damaged any.I’m as excited as a child on its first visit to the circus.I see I must read up some more.I’m going to get hold of Saleeby.I still think Spencer is unassailable,and next time I’m going to take a hand myself.”
But Brissenden, breathing painfully,had dropped off to sleep,his chin buried in a scarf and resting on his sunken chest,his body wrapped in the long overcoat and shaking to the vibration of the propellers.
CHAPTER XXXVII.
The first thing Martin did next morning was to go counter both to Brissenden’s advice and command. “The Shame of the Sun” he wrapped and mailed to _The Acropolis_. He believed he could find magazine publication for it, and he felt that recognition by the magazines would commend him to the book-publishing houses. “Ephemera” he likewise wrapped and mailed to a magazine. Despite Brissenden’s prejudice against the magazines, which was a pronounced mania with him, Martin decided that the great poem should see print. He did not intend, however, to publish it without the other’s permission. His plan was to get it accepted by one of the high magazines, and, thus armed, again to wrestle with Brissenden for consent.

